Yes, it was a cute thing when he was 4, but he still calls it "scarfing" a pumpkin, not carving! Although we have corrected him, he still says it, so that's what it is! Stephen had a blast since he got to participate this year. It actually went pretty well. As Christians, we try not to glorify Halloween, but Silas totally LOVES the pumpkin part, so I'm guessing this will be a yearly tradition. I want to enjoy it while it lasts. Before you know it, it won't even be cool to hang out with us, much less engage in family activites! So for now, we will "scarf" a pumpkin to our hearts delight!